Caution State Law Variances!
SECTION 107. ADDITIONAL LIMITATIONS ON OPERATING AGREEMENT.
(a) An operating agreement may not vary the effect of:
(1) this section;
(2) Section 103;
(3) Section 104(a);
(4) Section 104(b) to provide a protected series a power beyond the powers [cite this state's limited liability company act] provides a limited liability company;
Reporter's Comment to Subsection (a)(4) [Section 104(b)] – A protected series may have no greater power than the limited liability company act accords a limited liability company. However, nothing in this act precludes the operating agreement from reducing, restricting, or eliminating particular powers.
(5) Section 104(c) or (d);
(6) Section 105;
(7) Section 106;
Reporter's Comment to Subsection (a)(7) [Section 106] – This provision is less restrictive than might appear at first glance, especially with regard to Section 106(d) (extrapolation for subsection (a) matters which the operating agreement does not address). By its terms, subsection (d) invites the operating agreement to provide the applicable rules for filling gaps.
EXAMPLE: The members of a manager-managed series limited liability company learn of this act's extrapolation approach to subsection (a) matters, do not like the approach, and amend the agreement to include a definition of "disinterested" and further to provide:
If this agreement does not provide for a matter described in Section [citing the applicable provision of the state's LLC statute, as augmented by the act], the agreement is amended so far as necessary to provide for the matter. The amendment is stated and adopted by:
(i) the manager, if disinterested; or
(ii) if the manager is not disinterested, the affirmative vote or consent of all members owning a majority of the rights to receive distributions as members at the time the vote or consent is to be effective
(8) Section 108;
Reporter's Comment to Subsection (a)(8) [Section 108] – Section 108 contains the mechanics for extrapolation, which are non-variable. Section 108 is not self-executing; it applies only when invoked by some other provision of this act, each of which is also invariable. See paragraphs 7,14, and 19-21 of this subsection. But see also the comment to Subsection (a)(7).
(9) Section 201, except to vary the manner in which a limited liability company approves establishing a protected series;
Reporter's Comment to Subsection (a)(9) [Section 201]) – Under the exception, the operating agreement might, for example, decrease the quantum of member consent required to authorize establishing a protected series or grant the authority exclusively to the persons managing the limited liability company.
(10) Section 202;
(11) Section 301;
(12) Section 302;
(13) Section 303(a) or (b);
(14) Section 304(c) or (f);
(15) Section 401, except to decrease or eliminate a limitation of liability stated in Section 401;
Reporter's Comment to Subsection (a)(15) [Section 401] – The operating agreement may reduce the protections provided by Section 401 but may not increase (i.e., strengthen) them. However, an agreement between a series limited liability company and a creditor may certainly do so viz a viz that creditor.
EXAMPLE: A bank ("Bank") makes a loan ("Loan") to a limited liability company with the money to be used by the company. The loan agreement states that the three protected series of the company "are not party to nor guarantor of the Loan and have no obligation to repay any or all of the Loan" and that the Bank will have "no recourse to or claim against" the protected series "with regard to the Loan regardless of any legal or equitable claim Bank might otherwise have, except for an act by a protected series that is independently tortious toward Bank." Although this agreement can be seen as reinforcing or strengthening the horizontal shield, Section 401(b), between the company and the protected series, Subsection (a)(15) does not apply. The company's agreement with the Bank is not part of the operating agreement.
(16) Section 402;
Reporter's Comment to Subsection (a)(16)-(18) [Sections 402 - 404] – If an enacting state's limited liability company act states a restriction similar to Uniform Limited Liability Company Act (2006) (Last Amended 2013), Section 105(c)(15) (prohibiting an operating agreement from "restrict[ing] the rights under this ACT of a person other than a member or manager"), these provisions may well be redundant. See Section 106(b) of this act (providing that, if an enacting state's limited liability company act "restricts the power of an operating agreement, the restriction applies to a matter under this ACT according to the rules in Section 108"). However, not all limited liability company acts follow the uniform act on this point. And, for those that do, these provisions are useful for the avoidance of doubt.
Legislative Note: Subsection (b) is derived essentially verbatim from Uniform Limited Liability Company Act (2006) (Last Amended 2013), Section 105(c)(8). If an enacting state's limited liability company act includes the uniform provision or comparable language, subsection (b) is redundant and should be deleted.
(17) Section 403;
(18) Section 404;
(19) Section 501(1), (4), and (5);
Reporter's Comment to Subsection (a)(19) (Section 501(1), (4), (5)) – The operating agreement may not change the stated grounds for judicial dissolution but may determine the forum in which a claim for dissolution under Section 501(4) or (5) is determined. For example, arbitration and forum selection clauses are commonplace in business relationships in general and operating agreements in particular.
(20) Section 502, except to designate a different person to manage winding up;
(21) Section 503;
(22) ARTICLE 6;
Reporter's Comment to Subsection (a)(22) – Although the operating agreement may not vary Article 6, Section 604 incorporates by reference the merger-related provisions of an enacting state's limited liability company act. Some of those provisions are variable, especially, for example, the quantum of consent necessary to approve a limited liability company's participation in a merger.
(23) ARTICLE 7;
(24) ARTICLE 8, except to vary:
(A) the manner in which a series limited liability company may elect under Section 803(a)(2) to be subject to this ACT; or
(B) the person that has the right to sign and deliver to the [Secretary of State] for filing a record under Section 803(b)(2); or
(25) a provision of this ACT pertaining to:
(A) registered agents; or
(B) the [Secretary of State], including provisions pertaining to records authorized or required to be delivered to the [Secretary of State] for filing under this ACT.
Reporter's Comment to Subsection (a)(25) – This provision derives from Uniform Limited Liability Company Act (2006) (Last Amended 2013), Section 105(c)(3) (prohibiting the operating agreement from varying "any requirement, procedure, or other provision of this ACT pertaining to: (A) registered agents; or (B) the [Secretary of State], including provisions pertaining to records authorized or required to be delivered to the [Secretary of State] for filing under this ACT"). However, not all limited liability company acts follow the uniform act on this point. For those that do, this provision is included for the avoidance of doubt.
Reporter's Comment to Subsection (a) – To understand a prohibition listed in this subsection, it is of course necessary to read the provision stating the prohibition. Solely to provide a general sense of the prohibitions listed in this subsection, the following chart:
subsection (a) Reporter's Comment to Paragraph number - Section Number of Non-Variable Provision - Caption (or description if not full section)
2 - Section 103 - Nature of Protected Series
3 - Section 104(a) - capacity to sue and be sued
4 - Section 104(b) - powers
5 - Section 104(c)-(d) - no longer duration than series limited liability company; powers and purposes restricted
6 - Section 105 - Governing Law
7 - Section 106 - Relation of Operating Agreement, This ACT, And [Limited Liability Company Act]
8 - Section 108 - Rules for Applying [Limited Liability Company Act] to Specified Provisions of ACT
9 - Section 201 - Protected Series Designation; Amendment
10 - Section 202 - Name
11 - Section 301 - Associated Asset
12 - Section 302 - Associated Member
13 - Section 303(a) or (b) - initial ownership of protected-series transferable interest
14 - Section 304 (c) or (f) - duties of protected-series manager derivative claim provisions
15 - Section 401 - Limitations on Liability
16 - Section 402 - Claim Seeking to Disregard Limitation of Liability
17 - Section 403 - Remedies of Judgment Creditor of Associated Member or Protected-Series Transferee
18 - Section 404 - Enforcement of Judgment Against Non-Associated Asset
19 - Section 501(1)(4) (5) - Dissolution of the company dissolves each protected series of the company judicial dissolution
21 - Section 503 - Effect of Reinstatement of Series Limited Liability Company or Revocation of Voluntary Dissolution
22 - Article 6 - Entity Transactions Restricted
23 - Article 7 - Foreign Protected Series
24 - Article 8 Section 803 - Miscellaneous Provisions Transitional Provisions
25 - applicable generally to - provisions related to registered agents
or the filing office
JayNote: Section 107(a) sets forth the provisions of the UPSA that cannot be "toggled on or toggled off" by the Operating Agreement, and a provision in an Operating Agreement which attempts to do that should normally be unenforceable for that reason.
CAUTION: Most of the Section 107(a) restrictions are noted in the Reporter's Comment to the particular section restricted, but not always. The Drafting Committee discussed putting these restrictions not in a separate section (which became this § 107) but instead note these restrictions in the statutory language of the provisions to which they apply; that idea was discarded as unduly cumbersome, and thus this § 107 came about, but it essentially requires drafters to repeatedly reference this section to see whether or not they can do certain things in the Operating Agreement.
(b) An operating agreement may not unreasonably restrict the duties and rights under Section 305 but may impose reasonable restrictions on the availability and use of information obtained under Section 305 and may provide appropriate remedies, including liquidated damages, for a breach of any reasonable restriction on use.
This section states restrictions beyond those covered by Section 107(b). (Section 107(b) extrapolates to the protected-series level limitations imposed by an enacting state's limited liability company act on the power of an operating agreement.)
Occasionally the comments to this act refer to a variable provision as a "default rule" and a mandatory provision as "non-variable." These references are merely to draw attention to the default/non-variable distinction in particular contexts and have neither the intent nor the power to affect the default/non-variable status of the many provisions of this act whose comments lack a comparable reference.
ARTICLE 1. GENERAL PROVISIONS
SECTION 101. SHORT TITLE. SECTION 102. DEFINITIONS. SECTION 103. NATURE OF PROTECTED SERIES. SECTION 104. POWERS AND DURATION OF PROTECTED SERIES. SECTION 105. GOVERNING LAW. SECTION 106. RELATION OF OPERATING AGREEMENT, THIS ACT, AND LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY ACT. SECTION 107. ADDITIONAL LIMITATIONS ON OPERATING AGREEMENT. SECTION 108. RULES FOR APPLYING LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY ACT TO SPECIFIED PROVISIONS OF ACT.
ARTICLE 2. ESTABLISHING PROTECTED SERIES
SECTION 201. PROTECTED SERIES DESIGNATION; AMENDMENT. SECTION 202. NAME. SECTION 203. REGISTERED AGENT. SECTION 204. SERVICE OF PROCESS, NOTICE, DEMAND, OR OTHER RECORD. SECTION 205. CERTIFICATE OF GOOD STANDING FOR PROTECTED SERIES. SECTION 206. INFORMATION REQUIRED IN ANNUAL BIENNIAL REPORT; EFFECT OF FAILURE TO PROVIDE.
ARTICLE 3. ASSOCIATED ASSET; ASSOCIATED MEMBER; PROTECTED-SERIES TRANSFERABLE INTEREST; MANAGEMENT; RIGHT OF INFORMATION
SECTION 301. ASSOCIATED ASSET. SECTION 302. ASSOCIATED MEMBER. SECTION 303. PROTECTED-SERIES TRANSFERABLE INTEREST. SECTION 304. MANAGEMENT. SECTION 305. RIGHT OF PERSON NOT ASSOCIATED MEMBER OF PROTECTED SERIES TO INFORMATION CONCERNING PROTECTED SERIES.
ARTICLE 4. LIMITATION ON LIABILITY AND ENFORCEMENT OF CLAIMS
SECTION 401. LIMITATIONS ON LIABILITY. SECTION 402. CLAIM SEEKING TO DISREGARD LIMITATION OF LIABILITY. SECTION 403. REMEDIES OF JUDGMENT CREDITOR OF ASSOCIATED MEMBER OR PROTECTED-SERIES TRANSFEREE. SECTION 404. ENFORCEMENT AGAINST NON-ASSOCIATED ASSET.
ARTICLE 5. DISSOLUTION AND WINDING UP OF PROTECTED SERIES
SECTION 501. EVENTS CAUSING DISSOLUTION OF PROTECTED SERIES. SECTION 502. WINDING UP DISSOLVED PROTECTED SERIES. SECTION 503. EFFECT OF REINSTATEMENT OF SERIES LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY OR REVOCATION OF VOLUNTARY DISSOLUTION.
ARTICLE 6. ENTITY TRANSACTIONS RESTRICTED
SECTION 601. DEFINITIONS. SECTION 602. PROTECTED SERIES MAY NOT BE PARTY TO ENTITY TRANSACTION. SECTION 603. RESTRICTION ON ENTITY TRANSACTION INVOLVING PROTECTED SERIES. SECTION 604. MERGER AUTHORIZED; PARTIES RESTRICTED. SECTION 605. PLAN OF MERGER. SECTION 606. STATEMENT OF MERGER. SECTION 607. EFFECT OF MERGER. SECTION 608. APPLICATION OF SECTION 404 AFTER MERGER.
ARTICLE 7. FOREIGN PROTECTED SERIES
SECTION 701. GOVERNING LAW. SECTION 702. NO ATTRIBUTION OF ACTIVITIES CONSTITUTING DOING BUSINESS OR FOR ESTABLISHING JURISDICTION. SECTION 703. REGISTRATION OF FOREIGN PROTECTED SERIES. SECTION 704. DISCLOSURE REQUIRED WHEN FOREIGN SERIES LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY OR FOREIGN PROTECTED SERIES PARTY TO PROCEEDING.
ARTICLE 8. MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS
SECTION 801. UNIFORMITY OF APPLICATION AND CONSTRUCTION. SECTION 802. RELATION TO ELECTRONIC SIGNATURES IN GLOBAL AND NATIONAL COMMERCE ACT. SECTION 803. TRANSITIONAL PROVISIONS. SECTION 804. SAVINGS CLAUSE. SECTION 805. SEVERABILITY CLAUSE. SECTION 806. REPEALS; CONFORMING AMENDMENTS. SECTION 807. EFFECTIVE DATE.
- - - - -
Protected Series Agreements and Forms -- A list of the "best practices" agreements and records that all protected series structures should have.
UPSA COURT OPINIONS
- - - - -
NON-UPSA COURT OPINIONS
191212 ... Ohio ... Delaware Act .. MSP Recovery Claims, Series LLC v. Phoenix Ins. Co., 2019 WL 6770981 (N.D. Ohio, 2019).
181019 ... Florida ... Delaware Act ... MRP Recovery Claims, Series LLC v. USAA General Indemnity Co., 2018 WL 5112998 (S.D.Fla., Oct. 19, 2018).
2020.03.17 ... Series LLC Not Allowed To Play Pea-Shell Game In City Of Urbana Opinion
2020.02.16 ... Talisman Casualty Denied Diversity Jurisdiction Of Protected Cell Series LLC In National WW II Museum Case
2019.01.28 ... Understanding The Protected Series Act: Article 8 And Final Thoughts
2018.11.24 ... Understanding The Protected Series Act: Treating Out-Of-State Series
2018.11.18 ... Understanding The Protected Series Act: Mergers
2018.10.29 ... Understanding The Protected Series Act: Dissolution And Winding Up Of Protected Series
2018.10.21 ... Understanding The Protected Series Act: Liability Limitations And Claims
2018.08.30 ... Understanding The Protected Series Act: Assets, Members And Management
2018.08.28 ... Understanding The Protected Series Act: Creating A Protected Series And Service Of Process
2018.07.18 ... Understanding The Protected Series Act: The Framework of UPSA - Part 2 of a Series
2018.06.18 ... Understanding The Protected Series Act: What Is A Protected Series?
More articles on Series LLCs by Jay Adkisson click here
The Charging Order Practice Guide: Understanding Judgment Creditor Rights Against LLC Members, by Jay D. Adkisson (2018), published by the LLCs, Partnerships and Unincorporated Entities Committee of the Business Law Section of the American Bar Association
Now available for purchase directly from the ABA at https://goo.gl/faZzY6
Now also available at Amazon at Also available from Amazon at https://www.amazon.com/Charging-Orders-Practice-Guide-Understanding/dp/1641052643
Contact Jay Adkisson:
Phone: 702-953-9617 Fax: 877-698-0678 jay [at] jayad.com
Unless a dire emergency, please send me an e-mail first in lieu of calling to set up a telephone appointment for a date an time certain.
Las Vegas Office: 6671 S. Las Vegas Blvd., Suite 210, Las Vegas, NV 89119, Ph: 702-953-9617, Fax: 877-698-0678. By appointment only.
Newport Beach Office: 100 Bayview Circle, Suite 210, Newport Beach, California 92660. Ph: 949-200-7773, Fax: 877-698-0678. By appointment only.
© 2020 by Jay D. Adkisson. All rights reserved. No part of this website may be copied in whole or in any part without the express written permission of Jay D. Adkisson. Nothing herein is any advertisement or offer by the firm to practice in any jurisdiction where no attorney of the firm is licensed to practice law. This website does not give any legal advice or opinion, and is no substitute for the advice and counsel of an attorney consulted in the relevant jurisdiction. Questions about this website should be directed to jay [at] jayad.com, by phone to 702-953-9617 or by fax to 877-698-0678. This website is https://protectedseriesact.com